« The wire we REALLY need less of! | Main | Books—the NEW old medium »

January 20, 2007

Comments

RobiNZ

Yep, you're going to get the (mostly) SI Metric world to relate to cubic miles?

If Wikipedia can be believed it will be fine in Liberia, Myanmar, Thailand and USA.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Image:Metric_system.png

Bri

Yes, I think standardization of units is a great idea, but I agree with the miles comment... seems very US-centric, since the vast majority of the world uses metric. Also, since oil is a finite resource, I think using oil as the term of measure is not a good choice...

Stephen Downes

This example shows how elusive the concept of simplicity is.

As one commentator has already pointed out, the measure of '1 cubic mile' is needlessly complicated for a a world based on SI.

Moreover, '1 cubic mile' is meaningless as a measure. Nobody knows how much oil '1 cubic mile' represents. It is a unit outside our comprehension. Consider: off the top of your head, how many barrels is it? How many homes does it heat?

Third, the concept of 'oil' is not static. Oil comes in different types, some of which create more energy than others. Is the '1 cubic mile' West Texas Crude? Or what?

Fourth, one wonders how using a measure of volume clarifies a measure of energy. In an energy-conscious world, it may make more sense to educate people about joules than it does to make them imagine cubic miles of oil.

Keep in mind that one joule is the work done to produce power of one watt continuously for one second; or one watt second. And people *do* understand the concept of the kilowatt-hour - it shows up on their electric bill every month.

The main argument for the proposed system (ie., that we use a CMO as a measure) is that it is too difficult to use other measures. Of course, when they are stated as poorly as the authors state them, one cannot help but wonder why.

Consider, for example, "The Three Gorges Dam is rated at its full design capacity of 18 gigawatts." per yer? Let's suppose so - the authors don't say.

Then in the diagram we see that 1 CMO is equivalent to '4 Three gorges dams every year for 50 years'. Huh? How many Three Gorges Dams is that for one year? 200. Why not say one CMO (which is burned in one year) is equivalent to 200 dams (which produce 18 gigawatts per year).

Or, in other words, 36,000 gigawatts per year (gigawatt-years). One year is about 1 year = 8766 hours. That's 315 576 000 gigawatt-hours. That's 315 petawatt-hours, or 0.3 exawatt-hours (I'll leave the conversion to joules to you).

People can handle mega and giga (they do it when they use computers every day). The way things are going, it won't be long before they handle tera and peta. And - nicely - their system for counting units of energy will be the *same* as the one they use to count units of memory. And units of other things.

And what's so complex about 315 petawatt-hours? Nothing.

Looking at this article, I am face with two questions:

1. Why did the authors use oil as a standard?

2. Why did the authors use the mile as a standard?

It seems to me that such a nomenclature makes people think of energy in terms of imperial units and in terms of petroleum products.

And it makes everything else look like a *lot* - compared to the oil. It only takes *one* oil to make up 32,000 or so wind turbines (for 50 years).

How we talk about something says a lot about how we think about something, which is why there are such disputes about standards and nomenclature.

From one point of view, the use of CMO is 'simple'. From another point of view, the use of CMO is politically loaded and culturally specific.

That's why standards are so hard, and especially why discussions of them shouldn't be limited to engineers and should be presented as a "wonderfully short and simple article" in IEEE Spectrum.

Wayne H Hodgins

Thanks for the comments and observations Robin, Bri and Stephen. I too winced at the imperial units of miles in this CMO example! Being Canadian and have lived most of my life outside of North America, I'm all too familiar with the issue of the USA being almost the only place on the planet that has not yet seen the light and standardized on the metric system! And thanks Robin for pointing out that there are at least three other countries, Liberia, Myanmar, Thailand who share this condition.

As with much of my thinking, my point in posting this article was to more conceptual and abstract. This example of CMO was just a recent data point that was useful to put more focus on the concept and topic of simplicity, in particular for the purpose of increasing our collective ability to have better discussions, greater common understanding and make better decisions.

As Stephen notes, simplicity is indeed a tricky and elusive subject and concept. I suspect it is yet another example of how the simplest things in life often are the most profound and the most difficult to understand. All the more reason then for us to put more focus on and energy into this topic of simplicity and thanks again for your contributions to doing just that.

w
a
yne
=====

Juno888

The author of this post very idealistic i like it...

cheap ghd

All the more reason then for us to put more focus on and energy into this topic of simplicity and thanks again for your contributions to doing just that.

naked celebs

conceptual and abstract. This example of CMO was just a recent data point that was useful to put more focus on the concept and topic of simplicity, in particular for the purpose of increasing our collective ability to have better

round and brown

concept. I suspect it is yet another example of how the simplest things in life often are the most profound and the most difficult to understand. All the more reason then for us to put

black porn

conceptual and abstract. This example of CMO was just a recent data point that was useful to put more focus on the concept and topic of simplicity

jessica simpson naked

accusation thrust in secretly in the dead of night by an enemy, that doomed many an innocent man to walk the Bridge of Sighs

cheap nfl jerseys

conceptual and abstract. This example of CMO was just a recent data point that was useful to put more focus on the concept and topic of simplicity, in particular for the purpose of increasing our collective ability to have better

:)

NFL shop

I wonder how you got so good. This is really a fascinating blog, lots of stuff that I can get into. One thing I just want to say is that your Blog is so perfect!

pinnacle security

You will want to set up an escape route, as well as a meeting place as soon as safely outside, to see if all of your family members have created it.

nfl uniforms

this is my favorite version they released.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Become a Fan

Twitter Updates

    follow me on Twitter

    ClustrMaps